Barside
Download
Barside/Content/Intelligence · AI agents

Intelligence · AI agents

Relay.app shut down in 2026: where to rebuild AI workflows with approval steps

Relay.app's own notice says it shut down in September 2026 and that all accounts, workflows and run history were permanently deleted. To rebuild approval steps, Zapier, n8n, Make's Enterprise plan and Barside's approval inbox each pause AI work for a person in their own way.

Feature guideUpdated 15 min read

Relay.app shut down in September 2026. That is the date on the notice that now sits on relay.app, and the same notice says all accounts, workflows and run history have been permanently deleted. If you used Relay for workflows where a person approved or edited an AI step before it went on, you will rebuild them somewhere else, and the notice describes no way to recover them. Four places can take that job today: Zapier's Human in the Loop step, n8n's wait and approval steps, Make's Human in the Loop app, in closed beta on its Enterprise plan, and Barside's approval inbox for AI work that lives in your notes.

Everything on this page about Relay comes from its own notice, and everything about Zapier, Make and n8n comes from their help pages, documentation and pricing pages as we read them on November 6, 2026. We did not test those products or take screenshots, so each setting name is the one its vendor prints. We make Barside, a free desktop app for Windows, Linux and Mac, and the Barside section says plainly what it does not do. For a wider field, including AI agent tools, see our comparison of human-in-the-loop AI automation tools by how approval works.

Relay.app shut down in 2026: what its notice says

The notice on relay.app is short, and every fact about the shutdown on this page comes from it. It describes the product in one line, "Relay.app helped businesses automate their work with AI," and gives the date as a month and a year: "Relay.app shut down in September 2026." It names no day.

On data, the notice is just as direct: "All accounts, workflows, and run history have been permanently deleted." We found no export link, recovery route, recommended replacement or contact address on it. It links to a copy of the old homepage preserved on the Internet Archive, and it closes with "Thank you for building with us," signed by the Relay.app team.

Two things follow for a former user. Your workflow definitions are gone from Relay's side, so the only record left is the one you kept yourself, in notes, exported files, or the emails and records your runs produced. And because the run history was deleted as well, any record of who approved what now lives only in the systems your workflows wrote into, such as your CRM, your inbox or your documents.

Write down each Relay workflow before you rebuild it

Rebuilding goes faster when every old workflow is written down in the same shape, because the shape tells you which tool fits. For each one, note five things:

  1. The trigger. What started a run: a new form entry, an incoming email, a new row in a sheet, or a schedule.
  2. The AI step. What the AI wrote or decided, with the prompt if you still have it.
  3. The review. Who looked at the AI's output, and whether they only approved it or also edited it first.
  4. No answer. What should happen when nobody responds: keep waiting, stop, or go on.
  5. The result. What ran after approval: an email sent, a record updated, a message posted.

An example, to show the shape: a recruiter's workflow started on a new application in a web form, had AI draft a reply to the candidate, waited for the recruiter to edit and approve that draft, stopped if nobody answered within two days, and then sent the email. Written down that way, the needs are plain. A web-form trigger needs an app-connector platform, an editable draft needs a review step that allows edits, and a two-day limit needs a timeout setting that ends the run.

Relay.app human-in-the-loop AI automation: what to check in a replacement

A Relay.app human-in-the-loop AI automation review can no longer test the product itself, because the notice says the app has shut down and its accounts, workflows and run history were deleted. What you can review is how each replacement handles the moment a person steps in. We do not describe Relay's own approval features on this page, because the notice is the only Relay page we read and it does not list them.

Five questions sort the replacements quickly:

  • Where does the pause sit? As a step inside each workflow, or in one shared place where every pending item collects.
  • Can the reviewer edit, or only approve? If your habit was fixing the AI's draft before it went out, this matters most.
  • Who can review? Only you, people on your team, or people outside your account.
  • What happens on a decline or a timeout? For anything that sends or publishes, a run that stops is safer than one that carries on.
  • Which plan includes it? Approval steps often sit on paid tiers, and one of the four below is in a closed beta.

The sections that follow answer these from each vendor's own pages.

Agents that work while you don't · Open the video

Zapier: the Human in the Loop step

Zapier's help article on Human in the Loop describes a built-in tool that pauses a Zap at a step you choose. Its Request Approval action asks reviewers to "approve, decline, or change data you submit for review." That makes it a direct way to put an approve-or-edit step inside a workflow that connects web apps.

  • Plans. As of November 2026, the article marks it as available on the Professional, Team and Enterprise plans and unavailable on Free. On a Pro account, "you can only send requests to yourself." On Team and Enterprise, you choose who reviews.
  • Editing. A setting called Let Reviewer edit content? makes the content editable when set to Yes and read-only when set to No.
  • Decline. Action if reviewer declines is Continue run or Stop run. The default button labels are Approve and Decline.
  • Timeout. On timeout is Skip and continue or End run, after a wait you set in minutes, hours, days or weeks, and you can add optional reminders.
  • Notifying reviewers. By email, by Slack, or by triggering another Zap.
  • One limit. The article says you cannot add a Human in the Loop action within or after a Looping step.

If a send step follows the approval, choose Stop run for a decline and End run for a timeout, so a draft nobody approved cannot reach it. Our guide to AI email reply drafts with approval walks through that setup with Gmail, including a draft-only version with no send step at all.

n8n: the Wait node, approval emails and approval for AI tool calls

n8n's documentation describes three ways to hold a run for a person, and they suit different jobs.

The Wait node. The Wait node can resume After Time Interval, At Specified Time, On Webhook Call or On Form Submitted. Its Limit Wait Time option lets the run resume by itself after a set interval or at a set time. When the run pauses, the docs say it "offloads the execution data to the database," except for waits under 65 seconds. The node also gives you an $execution.resumeUrl variable, unique to each execution, that you can put in an email or send to another service. With On Form Submitted, what the reviewer sends back is whatever your form asks for.

Send and Wait for Response. The Send Email node has an operation that sends a message and pauses until someone answers. Its Response Type is Approval ("Users can approve or disapprove from within the message"), Free Text or Custom Form, and the default buttons read Approve and Decline. Limit Wait Time is available here too.

Approval for AI tool calls. n8n's page on human-in-the-loop for tools says "You can require human approval before an AI Agent executes a specific tool." The run pauses and sends the request through a channel you pick: Chat, Slack, Discord, Telegram, Microsoft Teams, Gmail, WhatsApp Business Cloud, Google Chat or Microsoft Outlook. The reviewer sees which tool the AI wants to use and with which parameters. On approval, "The tool executes with the input specified by the AI." On denial, the action is canceled and the AI is told. We found no option on that page for editing the parameters before approving, and the page asks you to say in the system prompt which tools need approval.

As of November 2026, n8n's pricing page lists Human approval for tool calls as included on its Starter, Pro and Enterprise plans. The same page says "A standard, self-hosted version of n8n is available on GitHub." n8n suits a team that wants to design the pause itself, down to the form and the time limit.

Relay app vs Make for human in the loop

Comparing Relay app vs Make for human in the loop now comes down to whether Make can give your team the review step it had before. Make's documentation for its Human in the Loop app says "The Human in the Loop app is available on the Make Enterprise plan." The same page says the app is in closed beta and available only to invited customers.

Make's integration page for the app lists four modules:

  • Create a review request: "Creates a request, returns a review URL, and sends the reviewed data to the defined webhook."
  • Watch completed reviews: "Triggers when a review was approved, adjusted, or canceled."
  • Cancel review request, which cancels a request, and List reviews, which lists existing reviews.

The integration page says Make "automatically pauses scenarios and holds data safely until your team is ready to provide input." A review can end as "adjusted," which points to reviewers changing data, but we found no page that describes what a reviewer can edit, and we found no timeout setting on either page.

On other plans, Make's help page for the Make AI Agent (New) app, which is in open beta, describes no step where a person approves an agent's tool call or output. We found no Make help page that describes a built-in approval step below Enterprise, so a human check there is something you build yourself. If you already run Make Enterprise, ask Make about the beta. Make remains a strong choice for visual scenarios with many app modules, as our Make vs Zapier vs n8n AI features comparison explains.

Make vs Relay vs n8n: the best AI automation tools with human in the loop today

For anyone who was weighing Make vs Relay vs n8n to find the best AI automation tools with human in the loop, the choice is now among Make, n8n and Zapier, plus a desktop option for AI work in your notes, since Relay's notice says it shut down in September 2026. The table sums up what each vendor's pages say as of November 2026.

ToolHow a person steps inCan the reviewer edit?If nobody answersPlan
Relay.appNo longer available: its notice says it shut down in September 2026 and deleted accounts, workflows and run historyNot applicableNot applicableNot applicable
ZapierRequest Approval step inside a ZapYes, with Let Reviewer edit content?Skip and continue or End runProfessional, Team, Enterprise
n8nWait node, Send and Wait for Response, or approval for AI tool callsThey can answer with Free Text, a Custom Form or your own form; we found no edit option for tool callsLimit Wait Time resumes the runTool-call approval on Starter, Pro, Enterprise
MakeHuman in the Loop app with review requestsReviews can end as adjusted; we found no description of editsWe found no timeout settingEnterprise, in closed beta
BarsideOne approval inbox for AI proposalsYes: tasks, reminders, email fields, a workflow's requestThe card keeps waitingFree; Barside Plus optional

How to choose:

  • Your Relay workflows started in web apps such as forms, CRMs or email. Pick an app-connector platform. Zapier documents an edit switch on its approval step, and n8n lets you design the pause yourself and can run on your own server.
  • You already pay for Make Enterprise. Ask about the Human in the Loop beta before you move anything.
  • Your AI workflows were mostly writing, such as recaps, briefings and drafts from your reading. Barside can hold those drafts in one inbox, as the next section explains.
  • A mix is normal. Keep the web-app flows in a connector platform and move the AI drafting to wherever the review feels lightest.

What Barside does with approvals, and where it does not replace Relay

Barside is a free desktop app for Windows, Linux and Mac, and what its agents propose waits in one inbox. Its AI agents and saved workflows do AI work in your notes, and anything that would change something for you waits in Agents & approvals → Inbox: tasks, reminders, email drafts and scheduled workflow runs.

On each card in the Inbox:

  1. Read the preview. Open note jumps to the note the proposal came from.
  2. Press Edit to change the tasks (one per line), the reminder text and time, or an email's To, Subject and Message. Undo edits puts them back.
  3. Press Approve. An approved email opens in your own email app as a draft, and you press send there. Barside never sends an email itself.
  4. Or press Refuse, then Refuse again to confirm. Keep leaves the card waiting.

Cards survive a restart, and the History tab keeps the latest 1,000 runs, approvals, refusals and errors on your computer. A scheduled saved workflow asks first as well: at its time, a "Run workflow" card with the full request appears in the Inbox, and you can edit the request before you approve the run.

What Barside does not do matters just as much for a former Relay user:

  • No app-to-app connectors, webhooks or web-app triggers. Nothing starts on a new form entry, email or CRM record. A workflow starts when you press Run, from the search bar, or on a schedule you approve. The recruiter workflow from the example above belongs in Zapier, Make or n8n.
  • It runs on your computer. Scheduled runs never start while the computer is off, asleep or locked, and only the latest missed run from the last 12 hours is made up. With Barside Plus (US$20 a month or US$200 a year, plus sales tax), cloud agents run scheduled agents on Barside's server, while saved workflows and the meeting agent stay on your computer.
  • The AI is the one you connect. Agents use the AI you connect in Settings → AI, and that company bills you for what they use.

Rebuild a review-first AI workflow in Barside

  1. Download Barside and connect an AI in Settings → AI: Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini with an API key, or OpenRouter with a one-click sign-in.
  2. Open the AI assistant and give it the job once. An example: "Summarize this week's notes in my Clients workspace into one status note per client."
  3. Under its last reply, choose Save as workflow, keep or change the Workflow name, and press Save workflow.
  4. Open Agents & approvals → Workflows, choose Schedule, pick how it repeats and a time, tick Ask me to run it on this schedule, and press Save schedule.
  5. At that time, approve the "Run workflow" card in the Inbox, or refuse it and nothing runs.

For call recaps, tick After each call transcript, prepare a follow-up on the Meeting tab, and the meeting agent puts a recap email, a Follow-up checklist and reminders in the Inbox after each transcript, with no workflow at all. The meeting follow-up guide shows how it keeps invented tasks out.

Privacy and where your workflows live

When a hosted service closes, its copy of your workflows closes with it, so keep your own written record of each workflow wherever you rebuild it. Hosted plans keep your workflows on the vendor's servers, and a self-hosted n8n keeps them on a server you run.

In Barside, agents, saved workflows and their notes live in your library on your computer, and saved workflows replace typed passwords, keys, tokens and card numbers with [removed]. When an agent or a workflow runs, its instructions and the notes it reads go to the AI company you connected, whose data policy applies. Notes and workspaces you leave out of Library AI are never given to an agent. Read how agents use your data and local-first storage and backups.

Works well with

Barside runs on Windows, Linux and Mac, and you can download it free.

FAQ

Questions and answers

Is Relay.app shutting down in 2026?

It already has. The notice on relay.app says "Relay.app shut down in September 2026." It gives the month and the year and names no day. We found no recommended replacement and no contact address on the notice, which closes with "Thank you for building with us," signed by the Relay.app team.

Can I export my Relay.app workflows or run history?

Relay's notice says "All accounts, workflows, and run history have been permanently deleted," and we found no export or recovery option on it. Rebuild each workflow from your own records: what triggered it, what the AI step did, who reviewed it, what should happen when nobody answers, and what ran after approval.

Which tools pause an AI workflow so a person can approve or edit it?

As of November 2026, Zapier's Human in the Loop step lets reviewers approve, decline or change data, on Professional, Team and Enterprise plans. n8n has the Wait node, Send and Wait for Response, and approval for AI tool calls. Make's Human in the Loop app is on its Enterprise plan, in closed beta. Barside holds AI proposals in one approval inbox where you can edit them before you approve.

Does Make have a human in the loop step?

Make documents a Human in the Loop app that is available on the Make Enterprise plan and, as of November 2026, in closed beta for invited customers. Its modules create a review request that returns a review URL, and a trigger fires when a review was approved, adjusted or canceled. We found no timeout setting described on Make's pages.

How does n8n handle human approval?

Three ways in its docs. The Wait node resumes on a webhook call, a form submission or a time, with Limit Wait Time. The Send Email node's Send and Wait for Response operation offers Approval, Free Text or Custom Form. And an AI Agent can require approval before a tool runs, asked through channels such as Slack, Gmail or Microsoft Teams. n8n's pricing page lists Human approval for tool calls on Starter, Pro and Enterprise.

Can Barside replace Relay.app?

For part of the work. Barside's AI agents and saved workflows do AI work in your notes, and tasks, reminders, email drafts and scheduled workflow runs wait in Agents & approvals → Inbox, where you edit, approve or refuse them. It has no app-to-app connectors, webhooks or triggers from web apps, so a workflow that starts on a form entry or an email belongs in Zapier, Make or n8n.

Is Barside free?

Yes. Barside is free on Windows, Linux and Mac, with agents, saved workflows and the approval inbox included. Each run uses the AI you connect in Settings → AI, and that company bills you. Barside Plus is optional at US$20 a month or US$200 a year plus sales tax, and adds cloud agents, cloud sync and encrypted cloud backup.

Sources

Where the facts come from

Checked on November 12, 2026. Products change: if something here is out of date, tell us at support@barside.space.

  1. Relay.app: shutdown notice
  2. Zapier Help: Request approval to keep your workflow running with Human in the Loop
  3. n8n Docs: Wait
  4. n8n Docs: Send Email
  5. n8n Docs: Human-in-the-loop for tools
  6. n8n pricing
  7. Make Apps Documentation: Human in the Loop
  8. Make: Human in the loop (Enterprise) integration
  9. Make AI Agent (New) app - Make Help Center